Shipping and returns

Choosing a carrier

When choosing a carrier, don't look only at the price per parcel, but also at surcharges, pick-up point coverage in your region and how customer service resolves problems. Calculate with your own parcel profile and test with a few shipments first.

Choosing a carrier looks like a sum: the lowest price wins. In practice, the carrier also helps determine whether customers come back satisfied, how many emails you get about lost parcels and how much time you spend on returns. This article walks through the three points to look at: price, pick-up points and service. You get practical examples from a webshop, common mistakes and a first step you can start on tomorrow.

Start with your own parcel profile

Before you compare quotes, you need to know what you ship. A carrier that is good for small, light parcels can work out badly if you mainly send large or heavy boxes. That is why average prices from a comparison table are worth little without your own figures as a starting point.

Take your orders from the past few months and look at weight, dimensions, destination and the share of international shipments. A home accessories webshop, for example, has many wide, light boxes that are charged by volumetric weight, while a jewellery shop mainly sends letterbox parcels. They need completely different profiles.

  • Average and maximum weight per parcel
  • Dimensions of your largest and your most common box
  • Split between the Netherlands, Belgium and other countries
  • Share of parcels that fit through the letterbox
  • Peak periods in the year, such as the holidays

Look beyond the price per parcel

The rate card only tells half the story. Many carriers charge extra for things like fuel, non-standard sizes, Saturday delivery, address changes or a failed delivery attempt. You only see these surcharges on the invoice, and with a small margin they eat into your profit.

So always ask for a complete overview of all surcharges and conditions. Then work through an example. Say you send two hundred parcels in a month and fifteen of them incur a surcharge. That weighs more heavily than a small difference in the base price. This is a worked example, not a rate.

  • Surcharge for fuel or peak periods
  • Surcharge for oversized or awkward parcels
  • Costs for a second delivery attempt
  • Costs for return labels and return handling
  • Minimum volume or fixed monthly fees

Pick-up points: coverage and accessibility

Many customers deliberately choose a pick-up point because they are not home during the day. A carrier with few points in your region, or with points that are hard to reach, will therefore generate complaints. It is not about the total number of points in the country, but about the distance to your customers.

Use a number of postcodes of existing customers to check how many points are nearby and what time they open. Also look at how long parcels are held and whether the customer receives a notification. A point that closes early or has a long queue damages the experience of your shop, not of the carrier.

Let customers choose at checkout

At checkout, you preferably show both home delivery and pick-up. Customers appreciate choice, and your figures show you which is chosen more often. If hardly anyone chooses a pick-up point, you don't need to put much weight on it in the negotiation either.

Make sure the integration with your webshop works and that the map of points loads quickly. A slow or faulty overview makes customers drop out, and that costs you revenue, however good the carrier is.

Service: what happens when things go wrong

On a good day you notice little of the carrier. The difference only shows when there are problems: a damaged parcel, a lost shipment or a customer who says nothing was delivered. Then you want to reach a person quickly and get a clear resolution, instead of a series of automated messages.

Before you sign, ask how a claim works, within what period you have to report it and up to what amount a shipment is insured by default. A common mistake is that entrepreneurs only read this when there is damage. It then sometimes turns out that the cover is lower than the value of the goods.

  • Is there a fixed contact person or only a general number?
  • How quickly is a claim assessed?
  • What proof do you need for damage or loss?
  • Can you track shipments yourself in a portal?

Returns and track-and-trace

Returns are part of running a webshop, especially for clothing and shoes. So look at how the carrier handles returns: does the customer get a label in the box, can they print one themselves, and can a return also be dropped off at a pick-up point? The easier it is, the fewer emails you get.

Good track-and-trace also saves you work. If customers can see for themselves where their parcel is, they ask fewer questions. Check whether the status updates appear automatically in your emails and whether they are understandable. A message such as 'in progress' without a time window doesn't help your customer.

Choose, test and keep track of what happens

You don't have to put everything with one party straight away. Start with a trial period of a few weeks with one or two carriers and compare real shipments. Keep track of how many parcels arrived late or damaged and how many complaints you received. That way you replace assumptions with data.

Your first step is simple: make an overview of your parcel profile, ask two or three carriers for a quote including all surcharges and ask about coverage in your region. Put the results side by side in a spreadsheet. A mixed approach, for example a cheap option for letterbox parcels and another for large boxes, often works better than a single choice for everything.

More on Webshoptiger

Frequently asked questions

Is the cheapest carrier also the best choice?

Not necessarily. Surcharges, damage and customer complaints can quickly cancel out a low price. Compare the total costs based on your own shipments.

Should I offer multiple carriers?

You don't have to, but it can help. Many shops use one carrier for letterbox parcels and another for larger parcels, so that each type of shipment ends up with the best option.

How do I know if a carrier has enough pick-up points?

Test with postcodes of your existing customers. Look at how many points there are within a short distance and what the opening hours are.

What should I ask about insurance?

Ask up to what amount a shipment is covered by default, which exclusions apply and within what period you must report damage. Also ask whether you can take out extra cover.

← All articles