Outsourcing fulfilment: when does it pay off?
Outsourcing fulfilment pays off when your time and space spent on order processing cost more than a partner's total quote. Compare what you currently spend per order on time, materials, storage and mistakes with that quote.
Many webshop owners start out by packing the boxes themselves. That works fine, until orders take over your evenings and your spare room. Then the question arises whether you should outsource shipping and returns. The answer depends on your numbers, not on a feeling. Below you can read which costs come with fulfilment, what it delivers, how to make a fair comparison and which mistakes you can avoid.
What fulfilment actually involves
With fulfilment, an external party takes over part of your logistics. You send your stock to their warehouse. As soon as a customer orders, the order reaches the partner through an integration. They pick the products, pack them and hand the parcel to the carrier. You remain responsible for your range, your customer contact and your marketing.
The range of services differs per provider. Some parties only do storage and shipping. Others also handle returns, gift wrapping, inserting flyers or labelling products. So always ask exactly what is included in the rate and what you pay for separately, because it is precisely those extra tasks that cause surprises on the invoice later.
A practical example: a webshop selling coffee accessories ships boxes every day from the owner's garage. As long as it is only a few parcels, that works well. Once the garage is full and the owner packs every afternoon instead of sourcing products, the problem shifts from logistics to growth that stalls.
Which costs are involved
Fulfilment usually has several cost items. You do not pay one rate, but a sum of separate components. Anyone who only looks at the price per shipped parcel underestimates the total. So request a complete quote and put it next to your own costs per order, so that you compare like with like.
Fixed costs count too. Some parties charge an amount for the integration with your webshop or a minimum monthly fee. With few orders, those fixed items weigh heavily on the cost per parcel. As a result, outsourcing can actually turn out more expensive than shipping yourself at small volumes, even if the rate per parcel looks low.
- Storage of your stock, often per pallet or per bin
- Order processing: picking the products per order
- Packaging materials, such as boxes and filling material
- Shipping costs to the customer, sometimes at a separate rate
- Processing of incoming stock at the warehouse
- Handling of returns
- Any set-up or monthly costs
What it delivers
The most important benefit is time. Suppose you spend an hour every day on packing, printing labels and driving to the pick-up point. You could spend that hour on purchasing, marketing or customer contact. For many entrepreneurs that is the real gain, even if it does not appear as an amount on an invoice.
You also gain room to grow. A warehouse absorbs a busy period, such as the holidays, with extra staff. When shipping yourself, you quickly get stuck and parcels leave the door later. You also get your living room, garage or office back, because the stock is stored elsewhere.
Note: faster delivery is not a given. That depends on the partner, on the times at which parcels are collected and on the carrier. So ask until what time an order is still processed the same day and how often collections take place, and test that during a trial period with real orders.
How to work it out yourself
Make a calculation with your own numbers. An example for illustration: you ship a hundred orders per month and spend ten minutes per order. That is well over sixteen hours of work per month. Determine what an hour of your time is worth, for example what you would otherwise earn or what you would pay for help.
Add the material costs, plus the space your stock takes up and your trips to the pick-up point. Divide the total by the number of orders. That gives you the cost per order when doing it yourself. Do not forget mistakes: a wrongly shipped parcel costs you the product, the shipping costs and the time to put it right.
Then put the total per order from the quote next to it, including all fixed costs and returns handling. The difference shows whether outsourcing pays off financially. Also calculate what happens if your orders double. Sometimes doing it yourself is cheaper now, but the tipping point is close, and then it pays to start collecting quotes.
Returns: the often forgotten part
With outsourcing, returns are a separate cost item. The warehouse receives the parcel, checks the product and puts it back into stock or marks it as rejected. Every step costs handling time and the partner charges for it. Ask in advance how the assessment of returns works and how quickly an item can be sold again.
The type of product matters a lot. A webshop selling clothing usually gets more returns than a shop selling lamps or tools. With many returns, fulfilment can turn out more expensive than you expect. So look at your own return figures for the past months and use those as the basis for the comparison, not an average from a brochure.
Agree who decides whether an item may still be sold as new and how you receive reporting on this. Without that agreement, you will have a discussion later about written-off stock. A common mistake is having returns sent to your own address while the rest of the stock is in the warehouse. Then you end up keeping track of two stocks.
Common mistakes
A common mistake is outsourcing too early. With a few orders per week, shipping yourself is usually cheaper and more instructive. You then see what customers ask, which products get damaged and which packaging works. You need that knowledge to give a partner a good brief later.
A second mistake is choosing only on the lowest rate. A party that is cheap but often includes the wrong products costs you customers and reviews. Ask how errors are reported, how you communicate with the warehouse and what happens in the event of damage or lost parcels. Put those agreements in writing.
Entrepreneurs also forget to test the integration. If orders do not come through properly or the stock is not in sync, you sell products that are no longer there. So always run a trial period with part of your range before you move everything over, and check weekly that the stock in your shop matches the warehouse.
Your first step
Start by measuring. For two weeks, note how much time you spend per order, which materials you use, how much space your stock takes up and how many returns come in. Without those numbers you cannot assess a quote. It takes little effort and gives you immediate insight into what shipping yourself really costs you now.
Then request quotes from two or three parties using the same data: number of orders, dimensions, weight and return figures. That way you compare on the same basis. Also ask questions about the contract term and cancellation, because a partner has to fit your growth. When in doubt, choose a trial period, so that you are not immediately tied in for a longer time.
More on Webshoptiger
Frequently asked questions
From how many orders does outsourcing make sense?
There is no fixed number. It depends on your time, space and margin per order. Work out your own cost per order and compare it with a complete quote.
Can I combine fulfilment with shipping myself?
Yes, some entrepreneurs only outsource standard products and ship special or large items themselves. Discuss this with the party in advance.
Who is responsible if a parcel arrives damaged?
That depends on the agreements and terms. Ask how damage, lost parcels and incorrect deliveries are handled and put this in writing.
Do I keep control over my stock?
Usually yes, through an integration or portal in which you can see the stock. Check in advance how often that data is updated.