What does a payment provider really cost?
Compare rates by converting all costs into a monthly amount for your own mix of orders, payment methods and order values. So look beyond the price per transaction: fixed costs, refunds and payouts count too.
A payment provider often shows one low rate per transaction, but you end up paying across more items. If you only compare the price per payment, you may sometimes pick the most expensive option for your own webshop. In this article you will read how to separate the costs, convert them to your situation and make a fair comparison.
What do the costs consist of?
The rate per transaction is usually a fixed amount, a percentage of the order value or a combination of both. In addition, some providers charge a monthly fee, a start-up fee or a charge for extra features. The rate can also differ per payment method, so iDEAL, credit card and pay-later options rarely cost the same. So you are comparing several prices at once.
The structure determines who benefits where. A fixed amount per payment works out favourably for high order values, because it does not grow with the amount in the shopping basket. A percentage is better for low amounts. Without your own figures you therefore cannot say which rate is cheaper; it depends on what your customers spend on average.
- Fixed amount per transaction
- Percentage of the order value
- Monthly or annual fixed costs
- Costs per payment method
- Costs for refunds and chargebacks
Less visible costs
Watch out for costs that are not on the front page of an offer. Think of a fee for a failed or cancelled payment, an amount per refund or costs for a chargeback. Payouts can also cost something, for example if you want them more often than the standard or have them transferred to a foreign account. Always ask for the full list of rates.
A common mistake is to assume that a refund returns the original transaction fee. With many providers that fee stays in place, and sometimes an amount is added. If you have a lot of returns, as a clothing webshop does, that adds up considerably in a month. So include returns in your comparison instead of treating them as an exception.
A practical example: a webshop selling household goods ships many parcels and regularly receives complaints about damaged products. Some customers ask for their money back via the bank instead of via customer service. Each chargeback then costs the order value and often an extra fee. Good product photos and a clear returns policy reduce that risk.
Collect your own data first
Start with your own data from the past three to six months: number of orders, average order value, distribution across payment methods and number of refunds. You get these figures from your webshop system or from the overview of your current provider. Without this basis every comparison remains a guess, because you are then comparing against an average webshop that does not exist.
Preferably choose a period without outliers. A sale week or holiday peak distorts the average order value and the distribution across payment methods. If you have seasonal differences, take a whole year or calculate busy and quiet months separately. A new webshop with little data is better off putting several scenarios side by side, such as low, expected and high turnover.
How to convert rates
Only then do you calculate the costs per provider. Multiply the number of payments per method by the rate, add the fixed costs and add the costs for refunds. Put the results side by side in a simple spreadsheet. That way you see immediately which provider comes out cheapest for your mix, and which item makes the difference.
A fictional calculation example, not a real rate: provider A charges 0.30 euros per payment and provider B charges 1 per cent of the order value. For an order of 20 euros, B costs only 0.20 euros and is cheaper. For an order of 80 euros, B costs 0.80 euros and A is much cheaper. So the order value decides.
So do not look only at the average order value. If your webshop has many small orders and a few large ones, the average gives a distorted picture. Split your orders into groups, for example below and above a certain amount, and calculate each group separately. That shows whether a mix of rates or a single provider fits better.
Look at payment methods separately
Not every customer pays in the same way, and that shifts the bill. In the Netherlands many customers choose iDEAL, but your webshop may also get many credit card or pay-later payments. Pay later often has a higher rate, but can also take risk and debt collection off your hands. So look per method at what you pay and what that method delivers.
A more expensive method can pay for itself if customers complete their orders more often with it. So do not drop a method purely on cost. A practical example: a webshop with expensive products sees that many customers drop out at checkout. After adding an extra method you can measure whether the number of abandoned orders falls, and only then decide.
A common mistake is to look only at the rate of the most popular method. If iDEAL accounts for most of the payments, that rate weighs heavily, but the other methods can still determine a considerable part of the costs. Make a row per method in your spreadsheet, so that you can look at the number of payments and the rate per method separately.
Payout, contract and integration
The payout period affects your cash flow. If you only get the money after a few days, or the provider holds back part of it as security, you need more working capital. A provider with slightly higher rates but faster payout can therefore still be the better choice for a small webshop that has to buy stock.
Also check the contract term, the notice period and whether there are costs when you leave. A long contract with a favourable start-up offer looks attractive, but can lock you in if your volume changes. Also ask what happens to the rate after the introductory period, so that you do not discover only after a few months that the price goes up.
Finally, check whether the provider connects well with your webshop platform, for example WooCommerce or Shopify. A favourable rate is worth little if the integration causes outages or requires extra development work. A failed payment due to a technical problem costs you an order, and that damage is greater than a few cents' difference per transaction.
Common mistakes and your first step
Common mistakes are: looking only at the lowest rate, seeing an introductory offer as a lasting price and not taking refunds into account. Many entrepreneurs also compare on the basis of an expected rather than an actual volume. That leads to a choice that no longer fits how your webshop develops after six months.
Your first step is simple: export the orders of the past months and make an overview per payment method. Then request a full list of rates from two or three providers and calculate them with your figures. Repeat the calculation as soon as your turnover or customer mix clearly changes, so that you do not keep working with an outdated choice for years.
- Export your orders and payments
- Group by payment method and order value
- Request complete lists of rates
- Calculate the monthly costs per provider
- Check payout, contract and integration
More on Webshoptiger
Frequently asked questions
Is the lowest rate per transaction always the cheapest?
No. Fixed costs, costs for refunds and differences per payment method can change the total. Always calculate the monthly total with your own figures.
How often should I compare my payment provider again?
Do so as soon as your turnover, average order value or customer mix clearly changes. A check once a year is also a good habit.
Should I offer multiple payment methods?
That depends on your customers. Look at which methods they use and whether the lack of a method costs you orders. Start with the methods your target group uses most.
What is a chargeback and why does it count?
A chargeback is a payment that the customer reclaims via their bank. The provider may charge a fee for it, on top of the loss of the order value.