Platform and technology

WooCommerce or Shopify: which one suits you?

WooCommerce is software you host and manage yourself, Shopify is a rented platform where the technical side is taken care of. With WooCommerce you pay mainly in time and separate services, with Shopify in a subscription, apps and transaction fees.

Anyone starting a webshop soon ends up at WooCommerce or Shopify. Both platforms work well, but they divide work and costs in different ways. This article explains where those differences lie, so you can choose based on your own situation, the time you have available and your technical knowledge.

The principle: manage it yourself or rent it

WooCommerce is an extension for WordPress. You install it on your own hosting and you are responsible for the server, updates, backups and security. In return, you can customise almost everything, because you have access to the code and keep your data fully under your own control. That gives you freedom, but also responsibility that you cannot delegate to a provider.

Shopify works as a rented platform. The provider takes care of hosting, security and technical updates, and you log in to a ready-made environment. That saves hassle, but you work within the limits of the platform. What Shopify cannot do as standard, you solve with an app or custom work, and that brings its own costs and dependencies.

How the costs are built up

With WooCommerce the basic software is free, but a running shop is not. You pay for hosting, a domain name, often a premium theme and separate extensions, for example for shipping, invoices or bookkeeping. These costs are usually monthly or annual and vary greatly depending on your choices. So you have a lot of influence over the total, but you have to weigh up every component yourself.

With Shopify you pay a subscription, plus often a theme and paid apps. Transaction fees may also apply, depending on the plan and the payment provider you use. These costs grow with your turnover, whereas hosting costs with WooCommerce grow less directly with your sales. So check in advance which costs apply per order, including for payments via iDEAL.

A practical example: an entrepreneur sells handmade candles and needs a connection to a shipping service. With WooCommerce she looks for a plugin and pays for it separately. With Shopify she chooses an app with its own subscription. In both cases there are costs that were missing from the first comparison. So first make a list of all the features you need, before you start calculating.

Costs you often forget

With both platforms the biggest cost item is usually time. With WooCommerce it goes on maintenance, checks and fixing faults. With Shopify it goes on setting up apps and finding solutions for limitations. Also include your own hourly rate or that of a freelancer, otherwise an option looks cheaper than it really is.

A calculation example, so not real prices: suppose that with WooCommerce you spend two hours a month on updates and checks. If you value an hour at an amount you choose yourself, you add twice that amount per month to your hosting costs. Set the Shopify subscription alongside it, including apps, and compare the totals over a whole year.

Management and maintenance in practice

With WooCommerce you regularly update WordPress, the theme and all plugins. An update can make another plugin stop working properly, so preferably test it first on a copy of your shop. You also arrange backups and security yourself or through your hosting provider. If you neglect this, you risk downtime or a hacked shop.

With Shopify this maintenance happens in the background. You mainly manage products, orders and settings. Faults in the core platform are the provider's responsibility, which gives peace of mind if you have no technical background. Do bear in mind that third-party apps have their own updates, terms and subscriptions, and that an app that disappears can affect a function in your shop.

A common mistake with WooCommerce is postponing updates for months because the shop works anyway. The problem then comes later, when you have to update many versions at once and don't know which change breaks something. It is better to schedule a fixed moment, for example a quiet morning each month, and make a backup beforehand that you have actually tested.

Flexibility and extensibility

WooCommerce adapts easily to special requirements: custom product options, unusual pricing rules, connections to your own system or a shop as part of a larger WordPress site with a blog. That can deliver a lot, but it requires knowledge or a developer. The more custom work you have built, the more you have to maintain later, and the more dependent you become on whoever built it.

Shopify is ready sooner for standard situations. You choose a theme, add apps and can be selling within a short time. For special requirements there are limitations, for example in the checkout. A shop with products in three sizes and colours usually fits just fine. A configurator with complex rules requires more consultation and sometimes a developer who knows the platform well.

Common mistakes when choosing

A common mistake is choosing based on the lowest starting price. With WooCommerce the start looks cheap, but maintenance and extensions come later. With Shopify the subscription looks straightforward, until the apps and transaction fees pile up. So compare the costs over a whole year, including your own time, and do so with the features you really need.

A second mistake is not thinking enough about moving. Transferring products and customer data is possible, but it takes work and can temporarily harm your visibility if product web addresses change. So don't choose only for now, but also for where your shop will be in a few years. Ask in advance how you can export your data and which parts you cannot take with you.

  • Looking only at the starting price
  • Not counting your own time
  • Overlooking transaction fees
  • Installing too many apps or plugins
  • Not checking how you can export your data

Which choice suits you and what is your first step

Choose WooCommerce if you have technical knowledge or bring in a developer, want a lot of control and already work with WordPress. Choose Shopify if you want to start quickly, would rather not manage the technology and want to spend your time mainly on purchasing and marketing. Neither is better by definition; it depends on what you want and are able to do yourself.

Start with a list of your requirements: number of products, payment methods such as iDEAL, a connection to Bol or your bookkeeping, and how much time you want to spend yourself. Then set up a trial shop on both platforms with a few products and a test order. That way you will notice within a few days which way of working suits you, before you commit money to a choice.

More on Webshoptiger

Frequently asked questions

Is WooCommerce really free?

The software itself is free, but you pay for hosting, a domain name and often for themes and extensions. Managing it also costs time or money.

Can I switch from one platform to the other later?

Yes, products, customers and orders can usually be exported and imported. Do allow time for checking and for keeping your web addresses, so you don't lose your search traffic.

Which platform is easier for beginners?

Shopify usually works faster without technical knowledge, because hosting and updates are taken care of. WooCommerce is possible too, but requires more management on your part.

Do I have to pay extra for apps with Shopify?

Many apps have their own subscription. Add those costs to your plan before comparing the total with WooCommerce.

← All articles